Skip to main content

How to Make Homemade Potato Salad

Homemade Potato Salad Recipe

I hope you like today's potato salad recipe. It's another one of my family's favorite side dishes. I now have many of my side dish recipes on the site. Once again, this is great for holidays, picnics or a picnic meal (just cold sides as a meal) or snacking. Make ahead for a refrigerated dish. Let's dig in!


  • salt
  • pepper
  • paprika
  • 4 cups of diced potatoes
  • mayo
  • mustard (may be omitted if you don't want a sour potato salad)
  • 3 to 4 boiled eggs
  • diced onion
  • dill pickle relish (may substitute with sweet relish)


  • Peel and dice 4 cups of potatoes.
homemade potato salad
  • Place them in a pot with water. Add salt.
homemade potato salad
  • Boil the potatoes until soft (test with a fork from time to time). Salt occasionally as they boil.
homemade potato salad
  • Boil 3 or 4 eggs while potatoes are boiling. I set a timer for 25 minutes as soon as I turn on the stove eye to start boiling. 
  • Remove from stove eye after boiling is complete and peel the eggs. See my secret for perfectly peeled boiled eggs in my homemade deviled eggs post.
  • When soft enough, remove potatoes from stove eye, drain them and place them in a bowl. Hint: these will finish at about the same time as the eggs.
homemade potato salad
  • Add a little more salt to the potatoes.
  • Dice about half of an onion and add on top of the potatoes.
homemade potato salad
  • Add 3 or 4 teaspoons of pickle relish on top. Include some of the pickle juice in the spoon as well.
  • Dice 1 to 2 eggs and put them in the bowl. Hint: you'll need to keep 2 boiled eggs to put on top of the potato salad later. 
homemade potato salad
  • Mix these ingredients together.
homemade potato salad
  • Add mayo for a smooth texture. I do not measure this, so see the picture below as a reference.homemade potato salad
  • Mix well.
homemade potato salad
  • Add mustard if you're using mustard. Again, I do not measure this, so see the picture below as a reference. Add a little more mayo if you're not using mustard. 
homemade potato salad
  • Mix well.
  • Add more mustard if you need to after a quick taste test.
homemade potato salad
  • Mix until all mustard is evenly spread throughout the dish. Otherwise, you'll have a mayo bottom as pictured below.
homemade potato salad
  • Slice the 2 remaining eggs lengthwise and place on top of the salad as shown below.
homemade potato salad
  • Add pepper.
homemade potato salad

  • Add paprika.
homemade potato salad

And you're finished! Refrigerate for several hours or overnight and serve! I would love to hear what you think after you make any of my recipes. Just drop me a line in the comments section below or via the Contact form on the right.


I hope you have a blessed weekend,



Other Posts You Might Like

Free Simplicity Cross Stitch Designs

I have been working on these free cross stitch designs for a couple of months, and I finally have the download ready to share with you. The free PDF download allows you to use for  personal items only , because this bundle (8 borders and 4 alphabet sets) of Simplicity cross stitch designs is a $50 value. Continue reading below to find out how to get a commercial license. Sample of some of the designs Drawing Simplicity  Block Border YouTube video of  6 stitches often used in Simply Making Life cross stitch designs If you wish to purchase the commercial license for $25, I have provided that button below the free download button. The commercial license allows you to make as many items as you want using these cross stitch designs. This does not give you rights to sell the PDF or any of the designs within the PDF. All details are inside the free PDF download. All rights belong solely to me regardless of any adjustments you make to these designs. Please give designer credit to Patri

Love My Granitestone Cookware

I bought my Granitestone cookware June 3, 2023. I loved these right out of the box. Now, after nearly 5 months of use, I'll have to say this is the best cookware I've ever owned. And I've owned lots of cookware since my husband and I got married nearly 35 years ago. I'm actually considering buying one of their knife sets too. If I do, I'll leave a product review on here for those as well.  Granitestone is not paying me for this review. If you know me by now, you know that I started this website to help other women in every aspect of life that I can. Why tell you about this today ? Because I cook our meals nearly every night of the week. And I feel that 5 months is long enough to tell you about these. They haven't warped yet like most cookware does - usually after the first use. These are very heavy duty.  I really like the glass lids so I can watch my meal more closely. These lids are also vented with small holes so I don't have to tilt them to vent. It is d

Vinegar to Remove Sticker Residue

My first vinegar cleaning test involved removing an old sticker and the residue that was on the bottom of a very old glass pitcher. I've had the pitcher in my possession for about 5 years and have no idea the full age of this pitcher. So, it seemed like a good item to try the sticker/residue removal test. In my head, the sticky residue is a germ catcher not to mention a plain old eye sore, so I actually try to get rid of that residue as soon as I remove any sticker myself. The idea is to remove goo from stickers, bumper stickers, labels, decals, etc. by repeatedly wiping with vinegar. So, first, I sprayed vinegar onto the sticker/residue section of the pitcher. I let it sit for about 5 minutes then scrubbed the section with a paper towel and my nail. The sticker part came off rather easily with some umph. I sprayed more vinegar onto the residue that remained and let it stand for another 5 minutes. With a hard push with my nail over the paper towel, most of the residue came off. So